Title Insurance Refinance Discounts

One key piece of the title insurance reform law that Think New Mexico successfully championed in 2009 increased the discounts available for homeowners who buy policies when they refinance their mortgages. (These policies are less expensive because the homeowners already purchased a title policy for the property when they bought the house.)

The new discounts are:

  • at least 60% less than the full policy price for a homeowner refinancing 0-3 years after buying (or previously refinancing) the home;
  • at least 50% after 3-5 years;
  • at least 40% after 5-10 years; and
  • at least 20% after 10-20 years.

In 2014, Think New Mexico successfully petitioned the Superintendent of Insurance to approve a new law ensuring that all homeowners will receive these discounts.

Unfortunately, data collected by the Insurance Division of the Public Regulation Commission has found that between 2009-2014, many customers did not receive the discounts to which they were entitled. As shown in the chart below, from May 2009 (when the law first took effect) through August 2010, only 26% of the policies purchased by New Mexico homeowners refinancing their mortgages received the new discounts (rather than the smaller discounts established by regulation prior to the reform law).

Here is a summary of the data reported to the Insurance Division by title insurance underwriting companies (a more detailed chart showing how calculations were made is available as a pdf here):

Title Insurance Underwriter Number of Transactions that Received New Statutory Discounts Number of Transactions That Did Not Receive Statutory Discount Percentage of Refinance Transactions Received the New Statutory Discounts
First American 1,685 3,880 30%
Fidelity 1,689 2,835 37%
Lawyers 436 1,876 19%
Commonwealth 116 1,939 6%
Stewart 292 593 33%
Chicago 0 595 0%
Old Republic 95 252 27%
Ticor 0 18 0%
Entitle 4 0 100%
TOTAL 4,317 11,988 26%

After sharing this data with New Mexico’s title insurance companies, we received several responses detailing how some companies are addressing this concern:

  • The Title Company, Inc. of Ruidoso, NM sends all of its refinancing customers a “borrower questionnaire” well in advance of the closing of the loan. The questionnaire includes a statement in bold type explaining that customers are eligible for a discount if they provide a copy of their settlement statement from the original loan closing.
  • Territorial Title of Las Vegas, Inc. contacts the “lender, real estate agent and /or consumer to obtain the necessary documentation” to provide the higher discounts.
  • Title Services, Inc. of Raton, NM contacts “the borrower or lender to obtain a copy of the policy or HUD I [settlement statement] for that policy.”
  • The New Mexico Land Title Association writes that it “has in the past and will continue to urge its members to ask customers for their closing statements or a copy of the prior loan policy if they happen to have a copy of it. This way they will receive the [higher] statutory discount.”

We encourage all New Mexico homeowners who refinanced between 2009-2014 to contact their title insurance company and seek a refund if they were overcharged. 

For more information, please contact the Title Insurance Bureau of the Office of the Superintendent of Insurance.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email